Op-ed
The "Novorossiya" That Never Was: How the Russian Empire Appropriated Ukraine's South
Today we present an article by Serhii Bilivnenko, historian, associate professor and head of the Department of Source Studies and Social Communications at the Faculty of History and International Relations, Zaporizhzhia National University:
In today's geopolitical vocabulary, "Novorossiya" has long ceased to be a mere administrative label from the 18th and 19th centuries. It is an aggressive ideological simulacrum, built by imperial propaganda to justify armed aggression, annexation and the physical destruction of Ukrainian land. To grasp how false and manipulative this myth really is, we need to turn to source criticism, oral history and the work of Ukrainian historians. It is precisely through fieldwork, microhistory and close reading of sources that scholars have spent years taking apart the colonial, chauvinist myths of a "wild", "uninhabited" or "empty" steppe that was supposedly waiting for the Romanovs' "civilising mission".
For a long time, the imperial myth tried to convince the world that the history of southern Ukraine began with the tsars' manifestos, decrees and charters. Yet long before the first Russian officials or foreign colonists arrived, this land had a life and character of its own. As the Ukrainian Institute of National Memory rightly stresses in its educational series "The South Without Myths: the 'Novorossiya' Concept", the steppe was never empty – it had its own place names, its own trade routes and its own long-established settlements.
In the early modern period, the indigenous peoples of the northern Black Sea and Azov coasts were the Crimean Tatars and the Nogais. Together with the Ukrainian Zaporozhian Cossacks, they formed a distinctive social, economic and cultural world on the steppes along the Azov and Black Sea coasts. There were Cossack homesteads, settlements and centres of the palankas (Cossack districts), as well as Nogai and Tatar nomadic camps, villages and market towns. By renaming old Tatar, Turkish and Cossack towns such as Kyzy-Kermen, Khadzhybei, Domakha or Mykytyne, the empire sought to erase historical memory, passing off rebuilt or merely renamed places as if imperial authority had founded them "from scratch".
Research by Volodymyr Milchev, Olena Bachynska and Vladyslav Hrybovskyi shows just how complex and many-layered this frontier society was. Drawing on close analysis of sources, Milchev describes the social order of the Zaporozhian Sich, the military settlers and other groups, and convincingly shows that Ukrainians made up the overwhelming majority of the population and were the ones who built up the region's economy. In her studies of the Danube and Azov Cossacks, Olena Bachynska shows that the Cossacks did not vanish from the southern frontier even after the tragedy of 1775, when the Sich was destroyed. Vladyslav Hrybovskyi examines in detail the complex relations, both diplomatic and everyday, between the Zaporozhian Cossacks, the Nogai Horde and the Crimean Khanate. Steppe Ukraine thus emerges as a distinctive meeting ground of peoples with centuries of history of its own, not as a deserted testing ground for colonial experiments.
The historical truth is that the Novorossiya Governorate, and later the Novorossiya and Bessarabia General Governorate, did exist as administrative units of the Russian Empire. However, as the analytical materials of the LikBez educational project (Historical Front) point out, the first Novorossiya Governorate was created in 1764 – before Russia had even reached the Black Sea or annexed the Crimean Khanate. It was set up on the lands of New Serbia, the New Sloboda Cossack Regiment and directly on the lands of the Zaporozhian Cossacks, and became a tool for drawing the region into the imperial administrative system.
The borders of this entity kept changing: the governorate was abolished, restored and turned into a general governorate, until it finally disappeared from the map in the second half of the 19th century. Most importantly, these artificial bureaucratic frameworks never produced a separate "Novorossiyan people". The imperial stamp proved powerless against demographic and cultural reality: Russian officials, landowning nobles and a handful of imperial administrators simply dissolved into the Ukrainian, overwhelmingly peasant population. Ukrainians remained the ethnic core of the South, and local communities – from multi-ethnic cities to Cossack settlements – preserved their Ukrainian identity and customs.
To trace the origins and evolution of the concept, it is worth turning to the key works of Petro Boiko and Viktor Brekhunenko ("A Pumpkin for Novorossiya" – in Ukraine, "giving someone a pumpkin" means turning down a suitor), Fedir and Halyna Turchenko ("The 'Novorossiya' Project and the Latest Russian-Ukrainian War"), as well as Oksana Poluliakh's articles for the StopFake platform.
As Oksana Poluliakh rightly points out, the pseudo-historical construct of "Novorossiya" was artificially revived by Kremlin spin doctors as a tool to destabilise Ukraine, divide its society and justify armed intervention. Tellingly, no natural or grassroots "movement for Novorossiya" ever existed in the Russian Federation itself. In Russia, "Novorossiya" was never seen as a real region – it was purely an export product of Russian militarism, imperialism and the "Russian world" ideology, designed for external aggression against the sovereign Ukrainian state.
In their work on urban development in the Azov region and the Lower Dnipro area (Berdiansk and Oleksandrivsk, today's Zaporizhzhia, in particular), Ihor Lyman and Viktoriia Konstantinova clearly show that the real economic boom of the southern cities in the 19th century came from integration into European markets, the work of foreign consulates and the efforts of local entrepreneurs, chumaks – Ukrainian ox-cart traders who carried salt and grain – and farmers, not from imperial myths or tsarist decrees.
Our picture of Steppe Ukraine as a region of many voices is rounded out by research on colonisation, particularly on Mennonite communities. Invited by the empire to settle these lands, the Mennonites brought with them a high standard of farming, a rational approach, agricultural innovation and a deeply rooted pacifism. They created unique centres of industry and agriculture. Yet, like other colonists (Germans, Bulgarians, Greeks), they did not change the fundamentally Ukrainian character of the region; instead, they became a natural part of its social and economic life. Later, together with the local population, they fell victim to Soviet repression, dekulakisation, man-made famines, including the Holodomor, and deportations.
Today, amid Russia's full-scale aggression, the very way we see our history has changed profoundly. The "Novorossiya" project, which the Kremlin conceived as a lever for carving up Ukraine, has collapsed completely and irreversibly.
The current Russian-Ukrainian war has become a powerful "nation-building factory". Through their heroic resistance, volunteer movement and everyday defiance, the people of Zaporizhzhia, Kherson, Mykolaiv, Odesa, Kharkiv and Donbas have proved that Ukrainian society is one and indivisible. The legacy of Dmytro Yavornytskyi and Yakiv Novytskyi, the work of today's researchers, critical analysis of sources and the oral history of Steppe Ukraine all make the case convincingly: the South is not "Novorossiya" but Ukrainian land – where the will of the Zaporozhian Cossacks was forged, where the memory of the indigenous peoples lives on, and where the phantom pains of a dead empire are finally fading away.